Well, it’s that time of year again: folks are bundling up, heading to family gatherings, huddling indoors, celebrating holidays and . . . passing the Kleenex.

Some employers are joining in—at least by reaching for the tissues—as recent jury verdicts on vaccine mandates and religious exemptions have started rolling in. Ever since the Supreme Court issued the 2023 Groff v. DeJoy opinion, which raised the undue-hardship bar, employers who want to establish that excusing an employee from a vaccine mandate would impose an undue hardship must prove that the worker remaining unvaccinated would be unsafe by a substantial, excessive or unjustifiable margin. That yardstick can produce a variety of results, as three recent decisions illustrate.

Read together, the decisions illustrate a fundamental premise: the outcome of the vaccine-related religious-accommodation fight turns less on the substance of vaccination mandates than on the presence of the unvaccinated employee in spaces that increase health and operational risks. 

A Transit Agency Pays $7.8 Million for Refusing to Accommodate . . .

Let’s start with the objectors who won: six former Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) workers, who lost their jobs after BART denied their requests to remain unvaccinated. Among 70 exemption-eligible employees, BART concluded it could not accommodate a single one without undue hardship. The jury disagreed, and the Ninth Circuit let stand the jury award of $7,824,580—more than a million dollars each—to the objectors.

BART made a few critical mistakes. First, it argued that any potential measurable uptick in transmission risk from any employee remaining unvaccinated constituted an undue hardship. The court rejected that premise outright, explaining that safety risks, like any other category of risk, are capable of justification—an incremental risk is not automatically an excessive one. Second, BART made an evidentiary blunder: the public-health guidance it claimed to have relied on never made it into the trial record. Third, and most importantly,BART made an analytical misstep. The objectors in question included a utility worker who was alone most of the time; a clerk who dealt with the public from behind a bullet-proof window through a slot and a microphone; and a technician who did roughly 90% of his work solo. (In other words, these objectors were likely not raising transmission risk much at all.) Plus, BART is in the transportation business, not health and safety.

The Ninth Circuit regarded the question of undue hardship as a classic jury question. Title VII, the court observed as it upheld the significant jury award, serves as a bulwark to protect the rights of conscience, and the jury represents the conscience of the community. What’s more, the panel noted in a pointed footnote, BART had taken in millions in federal pandemic relief, a sum that may have given BART the slack to accommodate a half-dozen workers, rather than fire them.

. . . a Hospital Pays Nothing for Saying No to Its Nurse . . .

Move the objector to the bedside, and the result flips. The Ninth Circuit (the same court!) also recently affirmed summary judgment for Oregon Health & Science University (OHSU) against a labor-and-delivery nurse who sought a religious exemption from Oregon’s healthcare-worker mandate. The nurse worked in a Mother-Baby Unit, providing hands-on care: feeding, bathing, administering medication and responding to emergencies for newborns, pregnant patients and immunocompromised cancer patients. Under the same undue-hardship standard that sank BART, OHSU easily cleared the bar, because undisputed evidence tied an unvaccinated nurse directly to health-and-safety, operational and staffing costs in a unit full of vulnerable patients.

. . . and a School District Gets to Send Its Teacher Home

The third objector neither won a verdict nor lost outright. Instead, a California appellate court held that placing a chemistry teacher on indefinite, involuntary unpaid leave was itself a reasonable religious accommodation (at least, under California state law). Douglas Smith taught for the Burbank Unified School District since 1992. When he requested an exemption from mandatory vaccinations and asked to keep teaching behind a barrier with masking and twice-weekly PCR testing, the school district said “no” to in-person teaching for any unvaccinated instructor and offered leave instead.

Smith’s lead argument was that leave can never be reasonable if it segregates the employee. The court disagreed, reasoning that unpaid leave eliminated the conflict between his faith and the job and preserved his right to return once the mandate lifted. Note the proximity theme again: the district had accommodated five exempt employees in isolated desk jobs with barriers and testing, but a teacher stands in a room full of students. And Smith lost the hardship fight on the record, not just the law—his insistence that one more unvaccinated adult on a crowded campus posed no real burden was, the court said, argument rather than evidence. (Still, he landed on his feet, taking a chemistry post at a school with no mandate and later declining Burbank’s invitation to return.)

The through-line for employers. Put the three decisions side-by-side, and it’s clear that the undue-hardship test is intensely fact-specific. Corporate employers may struggle to show hardship for low-contact workers, while hospitals or other high-contact spaces may be able clear the bar. The trilogy offers some concrete practice pointers: analyze each role individually rather than issuing a blanket denial, and remember that a creative accommodation, including unpaid leave with a right to return may satisfy your duty under the law.

Capabilities